HTSTLAJ

THE LONG
ARGUMENT

Three thousand years.
Eighteen chapters.
One instruction we keep failing.

CANAAN11 DAYS →

Start in Egypt, follow the wreckage, and watch the same argument survive every empire that thought it had ended it.

Egypt & Exodus

FUCK YOU, PHARAOH.
WHAT WERE WE THINKING?

Lesson attemptedHave somewhere to go
Lesson learnedNo
Years elapsedForty
Distance coveredEleven days
Progress toward stopping thinking like a JewNone

Sinai, Judges, the demand for a king

FUCK YOU, YOUR MAJESTY.
WHEN CAN YOU START?

Lesson attemptedLearn to live without a boss
Lesson learnedNo
Years mostly without a kingTwo hundred
Disputes settled in that timeOne. The stone moved back.
Progress toward stopping thinking like a JewNone

Exile, Cyrus & return

FUCK YOU, BABYLON.
WE TOOK IT WITH US.

Lessons attemptedOne
Lessons learnedNone
Temples destroyed1
Empires changed2
Countries lost1
Arguments lost0
Persian kings unexpectedly anointed1
Persian kings notified beforehand0

Hellenism & the Maccabees

FUCK YOU, ANTIOCHUS.
NOW WE’RE KINGS?

Lessons attemptedOne
Foreign king resistedOne
Temple restoredOne
Holiday createdOne
Dynasty createdOne
Kings acquiredUnfortunately
Steps completed toward not thinking like JewsNone
StatusFree, now with king

Essenes, Qumran & the Dead Sea Scrolls

FUCK YOU, EVERYBODY.
WE’LL BE IN THE CAVE.

Lessons attemptedOne
Lessons learnedNone
Jewish communities founded to escape other JewsOne
Rules writtenToo many
Calendars agreed uponZero
Messiahs requiredTwo
Arguments successfully escapedZero

Jesus, Rome & the Jewish revolts

FUCK YOU, ROME.
ALL OF YOU?

Lesson attemptedStop thinking like a Jew
Lesson learnedNo
Temples remaining0
Revolts against Rome2
Romevictorious
Argumentspreading
Unexpected convertRome

Yavneh, the rabbis, Mishnah & Talmud

FUCK YOU, GOD.
WE TOOK A VOTE.

Commandments inherited613
Commandments readapparently ten
Eggs eatenpending
Humanity approvedno
Divine interventions overruledone
Jews persuadeddon't be ridiculous

Christianity, Islam & the great Jewish export

FUCK YOU, EVERYBODY.
GET YOUR OWN FOREFATHERS.

GODSOne
RELIGIONS CLAIMING HIMThree
FOREFATHERS SECURELY RETAINEDNone
LESSONS LEARNEDFuck all

Crusades, massacres & blood libels

FUCK YOU, CRUSADERS.
WE LIVE HERE.

Lessons learnedNone
Sinful money returnedNone
Royal conscienceExcellent condition

Spain, Inquisition & expulsion

FUCK YOU, FERDINAND.
WHERE ARE WE GOING, PORTUGAL?

Instructions followedstill not sufficient
Lessons learnednone
Houses made portablewith difficulty
Portugaltoo close to Spain

Eastern Europe & 1648

FUCK YOU, COSSACKS.
WE JUST GOT SETTLED.

Lessons attemptedone
Lessons learnednone
Homes abandonedmany
Homes rebuiltmany
Kings requirednone
Committees requiredobviously

Spinoza & the herem

FUCK YOU, AMSTERDAM.
HE’S TWENTY-THREE.

Lesson attemptedEncourage independent thought. Somewhere else
Lesson learnedNo
Thinkers producedOne
Thinkers expelledOne
Distance maintainedFour cubits
Books banned before they existedOne
Pensions negotiated downOne
Placards posted0
KeysOne
Invoices sent to the heirsOne
Progress toward stopping thinking like a JewNone

Sabbatai Zevi & the false-messiah disaster

FUCK YOU, MESSIAH.
YOU’RE MUSLIM NOW?

Temples rebuilt0
Exiles gatheredat Gallipoli, during visiting hours
Turbans1
Houses sold by a man who didn't believe1
Adjectives left inall
Barrelsthree
Dried goods consumedtwo
Faithone barrel left

Emancipation & the Haskalah

FUCK YOU, GHETTO.
WE’RE EUROPEANS NOW.

Locks paid for by us2
Gates opened by Jews0
Gates opened by someone elseall of them
Gates re-closed by the pope who opened them1
Sanhedrins convened by an emperor1
Questions asked12
Question about moneylast
Approved first namesa list
Babies named twice1
Nations remaining, per the Assembly0
Nations remaining, per the Jewsask again

Dreyfus, Herzl & Zionism · November 3

FUCK YOU, FRANCE. APPARENTLY NOT.

STILL THINKING. CHECK BACK.

Pogroms, conspiracy & modern antisemitism · November 10

FUCK YOU, PROTOCOLS. WE DIDN’T WRITE THAT.

STILL THINKING. CHECK BACK.

The Shoah · November 17

NO FUCKING LESSON.

STILL THINKING LIKE JEWS.

NOW WE HAVE JETS.

November 24